Методологические подходы к определению недееспособности в зарубежной судебно-психиатрической практике

Полный текст:

Рекомендуемое оформление библиографической ссылки:

Харитонова Н.К., Русаковская О.А. Методологические подходы к определению недееспособности в зарубежной судебно-психиатрической практике // Российский психиатрический журнал. 2016. №5. С. 33-43.


Статья посвящена обзору основных зарубежных методологических подходов к судебно-психиатрической оценке  «capacity» (недееспособности и ограниченной дееспособности) при психических расстройствах.   Приведены правовые и клинико-экспертологические понятия, этические принципы, теоретические и экспертологические модели определения недееспособности: «the Grisso model», модель «видов повседневной активности», трехуровневая модель способности к финансовой деятельности, функциональный подход. Выделены основные направления зарубежных исследований в данной области. Обсуждается возможность применения зарубежного опыта в российской практике.


Ключевые слова дееспособность; дифференцированная оценка дееспособности лиц с психическими расстройствами; модели экспертной оценки дееспособности; функциональный подход.


1. Safuanov F.S., Kharitonova N.K., Zeyger M.V., Perepravina Yu.O., Khristoforova M.A. Complex forensic psychiatric examination of cases concerning restriction of legal capacity due to mental disorder: challenges and prospects. Rossijskij psihiatricheskij zhurnal. 2016; Vol.2: 37-43. (in Russian) 2. Korzun D.N., Tkachenko A.A. New tasks of forensic psychiatry in view of changes in applicable law. Nevrol. vestn. 2013; Vol. 2: 3-12. (in Russian) 3. Ilejko V.R. Some aspects of the problem of incapacity, diminished capacity in foreign law (review). In Pervomajskij V.B., Ilejko V.R. Forensic assessment: from theory to practice. Kiev, 2006: 257-68. (in Russian) 4. Marson D., Ingram K. Competency to consent to research: A growing field of research. Journal of Ethics, Law, and Aging. 1996; Vol. 2: 59-63. 5. Assessment of older adults with diminished capacity: a handbook for lawyers. Washington, DC: American Bar Association and American Psychological Association. 2005. https://www.apa.org/pi/aging/resources/guides/diminished-capacity.pdf 6. American Bar Association Comission on Law and Aging and American Psychological Association. Judicial determination of capacity of older adults in guardianship proceedings. Washington, DC: American Bar Association. 2006. https://www.apa.org/pi/aging/resources/guides/judges-diminished.pdf 7. Roth L., Meisel A., Lidz C. Tests of competency to consent to treatment. American Journal of Psychiatry. 1977; Vol. 134: 279-84. 8. Appelbaum P.S., Bateman A.L. Competency to consent to voluntary psychiatric hospitalization. American Journal of Psychiatry. 1980; Vol. 138: 1170-6. 9. Appelbaum P. S., Roth L. Clinical issues in the assessment of competence. American Journal of Psychiatry. 1981; Vol. 138: 1462-7. 10. Appelbaum P.S. Competency to consent to research: A psychiatric overview. Archives of General Psychiatry. 1982; Vol. 39: 951-8. 11. Appelbaum. P. S., Grisso T. Assessing patients' capacities to consent to treatment. New England Journal of Medicine. 1988; Vol. 319: 1635-8. 12. Grisso T. Evaluating Competencies: Forensic Assessments and Instruments. New York, NY: Plenum Press. 1986. 13. Appelbaum P. S., Grisso T. The Mac Arthur Treatment Competency Study 1: Mental illness and competence to consent to treatment. Law and Human Behavior. 1995; Vol. 19: 105-26. 14. Grisso T., Appelbaum P.S. Assessing Competence to Consent to Treatment: A Guide for Physicians and other Health Professionals. New York: Oxford University Press, 1998. 15. Marson D.C. Loss of financial competency in dementia: Conceptual and empirical approaches. Aging, Neuropsychology, and Cognition. 2001; Vol. 8: 164-81. 16. Grisso T. Evaluating competences. 2nd edition. New York: Plenum Press. 2003. 17. Uniform Guardianship and Protective Proceedings Act. 1997. http://www.law.upenn.edu/bll/ulc/ fnact99/1990s/ugppa97.htm. 18. Substitute Decisions Act. 1992. www.ontario.ca>laws>statute 19. Moye J., Marson D.C. Assessment of decision-making capacity in older adults: an emerging area of practice and research. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences. 2007; Vol. 62B (1): 3-11. 20. Nys H., Welie S., Garanis-Papadatos T., et al. Patient capacity in mental health care: legal overview. Health Care Analysis. 2004; Vol.12 (4): 329-37. 21. Berg J.M., Appelbaum P.S., Lidz C.W., et al. Informed consent: Legal theory and clinical practice. New York: Oxford University Press. 2001. 22. Checkland D. On risk and decisional capacity. J. Med. Philos. 2001; Vol. 26 (1): 35-59. 23. Horstman P. Protective Services for the Elderly: The Limits of Parens Patriae. Missouri Law Review. 1975; Vol. 40: 215-36. http://scolarship.law.missouri.edu/mir/vol40/iss2/1 24. Parry J. Decision-Making Rights Over Persons and Property. In: The Mentally Disabled and the Law. Eds Samuel J. Brakel et al. 3d ed. 1985. 25. Guidelines for conducting assessments of capacity. Capacity Assessment Office, Ministry of the Attorney General. 2005. 26. Kim S.Y.H., Karlawish J.H.T., Caine E.D. Current state of research on decision-making competence of cognitively impaired elderly persons. Am.J. of Geriatric psychiatry. 2002; Vol. 10: 151-65. 27. Moye J. Guardianship and conservatorship. In: T. Grisso (ed.). Evaluating competencies. New York: Plenum Press. 2003: 309-90. 28. Wolinsky F., Johnson R. The use of health services by older adults. Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences. 1991; Vol. 46: 345-57. 29. Marson D. C., Sawrie S., Snyder S., et al. Assessing financial capacity in patients with Alzheimer’s disease: A conceptual model and prototype instrument. Archives of Neurology. 2000; Vol. 57: 877-84. 30. Cramer K., Tuokko H., Mateer C., et al. Measuring awareness of financial skills: Reeliability and validity of a new measure. Aging and Mental Health. 2004; Vol. 8: 161-71. 31. Lichtenberg P.A., Strzepek D. M. Assessments of institutionalized dementia Patients’ competencies to participate in intimate relationships. The Gerontologist. 1990; Vol. 30: 117-20. 32. Appelbaum P.S., Bonnie R.J., Karlawish J.Y.T. The capacity to vote of persons with Aizheimer disease. American Journal of Psychiatry. 2005. Vol. 162: 2094-100. 33. Marson D.C., Mclnturff B., Hawkins L., Bartolucci A., et al. Consistency of physician judgments of capacity to consent in mild Alzheimer’s disease. The American Geriatrics Society. 1997; Vol. 45: 453-7. 34. Marson D.C., Briggs S. Assessing competency in Alzheimer’s disease: Treatment consent capacity and financial capacity / In Gauthier S., Cummings J.L. (Eds.). Alzheimer's disease and related disorders annual. London: Martin Dunitz. 2001. 35. Van Wielingen T.E., Tuokko H.A., Cramer K., et al. Awareness of financial skills in dementia. Aging Mental Heaith. 2004; Vol. 8 (4): 374-80. 36. Tuokko H.A., Morris C., Ebert P. Mild cognitive impairment and everyday functioning in older adults. Neurocase. 2005; Vol. II: 40-7. 37. Griffith Y.R., Belue K., Sicola A., et al. Impaired financial abilities in mild cognitive impairment: a direct assessment approach. Neurology. 2003; Vol.60 (3): 449-57. 38. Marson D.C., Savage R., Phillips J. Financial Capacity in Persons with Schizophrenia and Serious Mental Illness: Clinical and Research Ethics Aspects. Schizophr. Bull. 2006; Vol. 32 (1):81-91. 39. Revheim N., Medalia A. The independent living scales as a measure of functional outcome for schizophrenia. Psychiatric services. 2004; Vol. 55 (9): 1052-4. 40. Moye J., Karel M. J., Armesto J. C. Evaluating capacity to consent to treatment / In A. M. Goldstein (Ed.). Forensic psychology: Emerging topics and expanding roles. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. 2007: 260-93. 41. Moye J., Gurrera R. J., Karel M. J., et al. Empirical advances in the assessment of the capacity to consent to medical treatment: Clinical implications and research needs. Clinical Psychology Review. 2006; Vol. 26: 1054-77. 42. Moye J. Mr. Franks refuses surgery - cognition and values in competency determination in complex cases. Journal of Aging Studies. 2000; Vol. 14: 385-401. 43. Uniform Guardianship and Protective Proceedings Act (1997), http://www.law.upenn.edu/bll/ulc/ fnact99/1990s/ugppa97.htm. 44. Katz S., Ford A.B., Moskowitz R.W., et al. Studies of illness in the aged. The index of ado: A standardized measure of biological and psychosocial function. Journal of the American Medical Association. 1963; Vol. 185: 914-9. 45. Gurland B.J., Maurer M.S. Life and works of Sidney Katz, MD: a life marked by fundamental discovery. Journal of the American Medical Directors Association. 2012; Vol. 13 (9): 764-5. 46. Porter E.J. A phenomenological alternative to the «ADL research tradition». Journal of Aging and health. 1995; Vol. 7 (1): 22-45. 47. Parry J., Gilliam F. Ph. Handbook on Mental Disability Law. Washington, DC: American Bar Association Comission on Mental and Physical Disability Law. 2002. https://www.apa.org/pi/aging/programs/assessment/capacity-psychologist-handbook.pdf 48. Tepper A., Elwork A. Competency to consent to treatment as a psycho-legal construct. Law and Human Behavior. 1984; Vol. 8: 205-23. 49. Ganzini L., Volicer L., Nelson W., et al. Pitfalls in assessment of decision-making capacity. Psychosomatics. 2003; Vol. 44 (3): 237-43.

Метрики статей

Загрузка метрик ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM