Problems of organization of expert-diagnostic psychological research in various types of forensic psychiatric examination
Suggested citation:
Safuanov FS, Savina OF, Morozova MV. [Problems of organization of expert-diagnostic psychological research in various types of forensic psychiatric examination]. Rossiiskii psikhiatricheskii zhurnal [Russian Journal of Psychiatry]. 2019;(3):33-42. Russian
In this scientific review, pursuing the objective of identifying the main organizational problems of combined forensic psychological and psychiatric assessment in criminal and civil proceedings, we have carried out the analysis of the methodological materials pertaining to the execution of such assessments. For purposes of analysis we have used the questionnaires filled out by the medical psychologists who work as staff members at forensic-psychiatric expert institutions in Russia. Greatest challenges are encountered in the course of interaction between forensic experts and the agency or person who order an assessment to be carried out, as well as in the course of interaction between forensic psychologists-experts and the forensic psychiatric experts. We indicate the possible ways of overcoming these organizational problems. We identify the objective factors, which influence the complexity and the labor intensity of the diagnostic and the forensic expert activity of medical psychologists.
Keywords forensic psychiatric examination; psychological examination; psychiatric examination; organization of the examination; complexity
1. Mohon'ko AR, Makushkin ЕV, Muganceva LA. Osnovnye pokazateli deyatel'nosti sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertnoj sluzhby Rossijskoj Federacii v 2017 godu: Analiticheskij obzor. Moscow: FGBU “NMIC PN im. VP Serbskogo” Minzdrava Rossii, 2018. Vyp. 26. 200 p. Russian. 2. Shishkov S. Vozmozhno li proizvodstvo sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy v stadii vozbuzhdeniya ugolovnogo dela? Zakonnost. 2013;(10):37–42. Russian. 3. Kudryavcev IA, Morozova MV, Savina OF. O dolzhnostnyh obyazannostyah i normativah nagruzki psihologa ambulatornyh sudebno-psihiatricheskih ekspertnyh komissij i otdelenij stacionarnoj sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy: Posobie dlya vrachej. Moscow; 2000. 20 p. Russian. 4. Kochenov MM. Sudebno-psihologicheskaya ekspertiza: teoriya i praktika. Izbrannye trudy. Moscow: Genezis, 2010. 352 p. Russian. 5. Kudryavcev IA. Sudebnaya psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza. Moscow: YUridicheskaya literatura, 1988. 224 p. Russian. 6. Kudryavcev IA. Kompleksnaya sudebnaya psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza. Moscow: Izdatel'ctvo Moskovskogo universiteta, 1999. 497 p. Russian. 7. Safuanov FS. Sudebno-psihologicheskaya ekspertiza: uchebnik dlya akademicheskogo bakalavriata. Moscow: Yurajt, 2014. 421 p. Russian. 8. Makushkin ЕV, Badmaeva VD, Dozorceva ЕG, et al. Integrativnye vyvody i kompleksaciya specialistov pri kompleksnoj psihologo-psihiatricheskoj ekspertize nesovershennoletnih obvinyaemyh: Metodicheskie rekomendacii. Moscow: FMICPN im. VP Serbskogo, 2016. 24 p. Russian. 9. Makushkin ЕV, Badmaeva VD, Dozorceva ЕG, et al. Kompleksnaya psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ocenka diagnosticheski slozhnyh psihicheskih sostoyanij u nesovershennoletnih obvinyaemyh. Sudebno-psihiatricheskaya diagnostika. Pod red. ЕV Makushkina, AA Tkachenko. Moscow; 2017. P. 288–386. Russian. 10. Makushkin ЕV, Badmaeva VD, Dozorceva ЕG, et al. Kompleksnaya psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza nesovershennoletnih obvinyaemyh v ugolovnom processe: Rukovodstvo dlya vrachej. Moscow: Nestor-Istoriya, 2014. 124 p. Russian. 11. Makushkin ЕV, Dozorceva ЕG, Badmaeva VD, et al. Kompleksnaya sudebnaya psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza nesovershennoletnih: Metodicheskie rekomendacii. Moscow: GNC SSP im. VP Serbskogo, 2011. 28 p. Russian. 12. Kudryavcev IA, Lavrinovich AN, Moskalenko ЕP, Safuanov FS. Osobennosti patopsihologicheskoj kvalifikacii rezul'tatov eksperimental'no-psihologicheskogo issledovaniya v usloviyah sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy: Metodicheskie rekomendacii. Moscow: GNC SSP im. VP Serbskogo, 1985. 27 p. Russian. 13. Safuanov FS, Savina OF, Morozova MV, Isaeva IV. Kriterii sudebno-psihologicheskoj ekspertnoj ocenki yuridicheski relevantnyh emocional'nyh sostoyanij u obvinyaemyh: Metodicheskie rekomendacii. Moscow: FGBU “FMICPN im. VP Serbskogo” Minzdrava Rossii, 2016. 28 p. Russian. 14. Haritonova NK, Safuanov FS, Malkin DA. Ekspertnaya ocenka sdelkosposobnosti po grazhdanskim delam v ramkah kompleksnoj sudebnoj psihologo-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy: Posobie dlya vrachej. Moscow: GNC SSP im. VP Serbskogo, 2005. 30 p. Russian. 15. Dmitrieva TB, Haritonova NK, Immerman KL, Koroleva ЕV. Sudebno-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza v grazhdanskom processe. SPb.: YUrid. centr Press, 2003. 251 p. Russian. 16. Korzun DN. K probleme ogranichennoj deesposobnosti vsledstvie psihicheskogo rasstrojstva. Sudebnaya psihiatriya. Aktual'nye problemy. Moscow: GNC SSP im. VP Serbskogo, 2014. P. 101–14. Russian. 17. Sekerazh TN, Shipshin SS. Metodicheskie rekomendacii po proizvodstvu sudebnoj psihologicheskoj ekspertizy po delam o priznanii sdelok s “porokami voli”. Moscow: RFCSE pri Minyuste Rossii, 2014. 65 p. Russian. 18. Shishkov SN. Nepredskazuemye sobytiya, vliyayushchie na naznachenie i proizvodstvo sudebno-psihiatricheskih ekspertiz (“chernye lebedi” sudebnoj psihiatrii). Rossiiskii psikhiatricheskii zhurnal [Russian Journal of Psychiatry]. 2017;(1):20–5. Russian. 19. Potemkin BЕ, Tkachenko AA. Faktory, opredelyayushchie slozhnost' klinicheskoj diagnostiki v usloviyah sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy. Psihicheskoe zdorov'e. 2017;(12):55–67. Russian. 20. Potemkin BЕ, Tkachenko AA. Ocenka slozhnosti ambulatornyh sudebno-psihiatricheskih ekspertiz. Obozrenie psihiatrii i medicinskoj psihologii im. VM Bekhtereva. 2019;(1):93–101. Russian. 21. Protokol vedeniya bol'nyh. Sudebno-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza. Normativno-pravovye dokumenty po sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertize. Moscow: FGU “GNC SSP Roszdrava”, 2007. P. 15–122. Russian. 22. Rukovodstvo po sudebnoj psihiatrii. Pod red. AA Tkachenko. Prakticheskoe posobie. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo YUrajt, 2015. 966 p. Russian. 23. Dozorceva ЕG, Makushkin ЕV, Badmaeva VD, et al. Psihologicheskie aspekty psihicheskoj travmy u nesovershennoletnih poterpevshih ot prestuplenij. Analiticheskij obzor. Moscow: FMIC PN im. VP Serbskogo, 2016. 32 p. Russian. 24. Nuckova ЕV. Diagnosticheskaya i ekspertnaya ocenka psihologicheskih posledstvij seksual'nogo nasiliya i zloupotrebleniya v otnoshenii devochek [Elektronnyj resurs]. Psihologiya i pravo. 2018;8(4):75–98. Russian. 25. Shipshin SS. Ispol'zovanie psihologicheskih znanij pri rassledovanii seksual'nyh prestuplenij, sovershaemyh v otnoshenii nesovershennoletnih: problemy i resheniya. Psihologicheskie osobennosti uchastnikov ugolovnogo processa. Pod red. OD Sitkovskoj. Moscow: Universitet prokuratury Rossijskoj Federacii. 2018. P. 102–10. Russian. 26. Safuanov FS, Haritonova NK, Rusakovskaya OA. Psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza po sudebnym sporam mezhdu roditelyami o vospitanii i meste zhitel'stva rebenka. Moscow: Genezis, 2011. 192 p. Russian. 27. Gor'kovaya IA. Problemnye polya sudebno-psihologicheskoj ekspertizy o prave na vospitanie detej. Prikladnaya yuridicheskaya psihologiya. 2017;(1):55–61. Russian. 28. Tkachenko AA. Pravovye i metodologicheskie osnovy Zaklyucheniya sudebno-psihiatricheskogo eksperta (komissii sudebno-psihiatricheskih ekspertov). Posobie dlya vrachej. Moscow; 2006. 64 p. Russian. 29. Shlyahov AR. Teoriya i praktika kompleksnyh issledovanij v sudebno-ekspertnyh uchrezhdeniyah sistemy MYU SSSR. Problemy organizacii i provedeniya kompleksnyh ekspertnyh issledovanij. Moscow; 1985. P. 5–10. Russian. 30. Ambarcumyan ES, Ivanov PA, Sel'kin VA. Ponyatie “sushchestvennoe vliyanie” i ego sudebnaya ocenka. Praktika sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy: Sb. № 47. Moscow: FGU “GNC SSP Roszdrava”, 2009. P. 196–209. Russian. 31. Kudryavcev IA, Pechernikova TP, Azbukina VD, et al. O diagnosticheskoj informativnosti nekotoryh patopsihologicheskih simptomokompleksov. Sudebno-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza lic pozhilogo i starcheskogo vozrasta: Sb. nauchnyh trudov № 37. Moscow; 1981. P. 85–91. Russian. 32. Pechernikova TP, Pelipas VЕ, Filipskih VЕ. Katamnesticheskoe obsledovanie lic s simulyativnym povedeniem, priznannyh vmenyaemymi. Teoreticheskie i organizacionnye voprosy sudebnoj psihiatrii. Moscow; 1978. P. 35–45. Russian. 33. Potemkin BЕ, Tkachenko AA. Vliyanie atipichnosti klinicheskoj kartiny na “slozhnost'” sudebno-psihiatricheskoj diagnostiki. Social'naya i klinicheskaya psihiatriya. 2016;(3):58–64. Russian. 34. Syrokvashina KV, Oshevskij DS, Badmaeva VD, et al. Faktory riska formirovaniya suicidal'nogo povedeniya u detej i podrostkov (po rezul'tatam analiza regional'nyh posmertnyh sudebnyh ekspertiz). Psihologiya i pravo. 2019;9(1):71–84. Russian. 35. Haritonova NK, Rusakovskaya OA. Kompleksnaya psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza po sporam o poryadke vospitaniya detej roditelyami, prozhivayushchimi razdel'no. Sudebno-psihiatricheskaya diagnostika. Moscow: NMIC PN im. VP Serbskogo, 2017. P. 601–25. Russian. 36. Makushkin ЕV, Badmaeva VD, Dozorceva ЕG, et al. Podgotovka materialov sledovatelyami dlya proizvodstva posmertnoj kompleksnoj sudebnoj psihologo-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy nesovershennoletnih, okonchivshih zhizn' samoubijstvom (stat'ya 110 UK RF). Metodicheskie rekomendacii. Moscow: NMIC PN im. VP Serbskogo, 2018. 20 p. Russian. 37. Dozorceva ЕG. Psihologo-psihiatricheskaya ekspertiza nesovershennoletnih: problemnye voprosy. Voprosy ekspertnoj praktiki. 2017;(S1):81–4. Russian. 38. Korzun DN, Tkachenko AA. Rol' razlichnyh istochnikov informacii pri proizvodstve sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy. Sudebnaya psihiatriya. Aktual'nye problemy. Vyp. 9. Moscow: GNC SSP im. VP Serbskogo, 2012. P. 102–11. Russian. 39. Dmitrieva TB, Shishkov SN, Shchukina ЕYA, et al. Podgotovka sledovatelem materialov dlya sudebno-psihiatricheskoj ekspertizy: Prakticheskoe posobie. Moscow: FGU “GNC SSP Roszdrava”, 2010. 62 p. Russian.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24411/1560-957X-2019-11926
Article Metrics
Metrics powered by PLOS ALM