Law on Psychiatric Care: Twenty-Five Years in Action
Suggested citation:
Polubinskaya SV, Shishkov SN. [Law on Psychiatric Care: Twenty-Five Years in Action]. Rossiiskii psikhiatricheskii zhurnal [Russian Journal of Psychiatry]. 2018;(2):63-73. Russian
The article discusses the history of the legal regulation of psychiatric care in Russia, describes the conceptual ideas of the Russian Federation Law "On psychiatric care and guarantees of citizens’ rights in its provision" – the first Federal law in this area, provides statistical data on its application. Analysis of changes made to the Law over 25 years of its action shows that they did not affect either its concept, or the most fundamental provisions. However, not all changes of the Law on Psychiatric Care can be considered successful. In addition, the adoption of new laws and amendments to existing ones leads to an increase in the number of conflicting legal norms concerning psychiatry. In this regard, one of the recent tasks of improving the legislation is to eliminate such contradictions.
Keywords psychiatric care; the law; Russian Federation; a mental disorder; involuntary measures; a court; control; doctor; patient
1. Blyudina U. Bor’ba s narkomaniey v sovremennoy Rossii: vzglyad sociologa prava. Ul’yanovsk; 2006. 300 p. Russian. 2. Borodin SV, Polubinskaya SV. Pravovoe regulirovanie psykhiatricheskoy pomoshh. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo. 1988;(5):72-9. Russian. 3. Gurovich IYa, Golland VB, Zaychenko NM. Dinamika pokazateley deyatel’nosti psikhiatricheskoy sluzhby (1994-1999 g.). Moscow; 2000. 508 p. Russian. 4. Gurovich IYa. [Reform of Psychiatric Care System: Organizational aspect]. Social’naya i klinicheskaya psykhiatriya [Social and Clinical Psychiatry]. 2005;15(4):12-7. Russian. 5. Gurovich IYa, Shmukler AB, Golland VB, Zaychenko NM. Psykhiatricheskaya sluzhba v Rossiyskoy Federatsii v 2006-2011 gg. (dinamika pokazateley i analiz processov razvitiya). Moscow; 2012. 600 p. Russian. 6. Gurovich IYa. [The State of Psychiatric Care System in Russia: Current Challenges against Background Shrinking of the In-patient Care]. Social’naya i klinicheskaya psikhiatriya [Social and Clinical Psychiatry]. 2012;22(4):5-9. Russian. 7. Dmitrieva TB. Al’yans prava I miloserdiya: O probleme zashhity prav cheloveka v psikhiatrii. Moscow; 2001. 156 p. Russian. 8. Dmitrieva TB (ed). Zakonodatel’stvo Rossiyskoy Federatsii v pblasti psikhiatrii: Kommentariy k Zakonu RF «O psikhiatricheskoy pomoshhi I garantiyakh prav grazhdan pri ee okazanii», GK I UK RF (v chasti, kasayushheysya lic s psikhicheskimi rasstroystvami). Moscow; 2002. 383 p. Russian. 9. Zakharova NA, Belyaninova YuV, Savina LV, Kolokolov GR, Egorov YuV. Nauchno-practicheskiy kommenariy k Zakonu RF ot 2 iyulya 1992 g. N 3185-I «O psikhiatricheskoy pomoshhi I garantiyakh prav grazhdan pri ee okazanii». 2017. Available at: http://www.garant.ru (Assessed: 27.12.2017). Russian. 10. Kodeks professional’noy etiki psikhiatra. Available at: http://psychiatr.ru/about/code (Assessed: 4.01.2018). Russian. 11. Kommentariy k zakonodatel’stvu Rossiyskoy Federtsii v oblasti psikhiatrii / Koll. avtorov. Pod obshh. red. TB Dmitrievoy. Moscow;1997. 363 p. Russian. 12. Nikulinskaya NF, Novikova EE, Korneeva OV, Vakhrusheva YuN. Kommentaiy k Zakonu RF ot 2 iylya 1992 g. N 3185-1 «O psikhiatricheskoy pomoshhi i garantiyakh prav grazhdan pro ee okazanii» (postateynyi). SPS KonsultantPlus. 2013. Available at: http://cons-plus.ru. (Assessed: 27.12.2017). Russian. 13. Nikulinskaya NF, Novikova EE, Korneeva OV, Vakhrusheva YuN. Kommentaiy k Zakonu RF ot 2 iylya 1992 g. N 3185-1 «O psikhiatricheskoy pomoshhi i garantiyakh prav grazhdan pro ee okazanii». Special’no dlya sistemy GARANT. 2014. Available at from: http://www.garant.ru (Assessed: 27.12.2017). Russian. 14. Borodin SV, Kotova VP. (Eds). O psikhiatricheskoy pomoshhi i garantiyakh prav grazhdan pri ee okazanii: Postateynyi kommentariy k Zakonu Rossii. Moscow; 1993. 239 p. Russian. 15. Polotnyanko AN, Tereshhenko IS, Vologzhanina GA. Modeli vzaimodeystviya «vrach-pacient» v ostrom psikhiatricheskom stacionare. In: Pravovye i eticheskie problemy psykhiatricheskoy pomoshhi: materially nauchno-prakticheskoy ronferencii. 30 november 2009 g. Moscow; 2009. p. 143-144. Russian. 16. Psikhicheskie rasstroystva i rasstroystva povedeniya (F00 - F99). Klass V MKB-10, adaptirovannyi dlya ispol’zovaniya v Rossiyskoy Federatsii. Moscow; 1998. Available at: http://psychiatr.ru/download/1998?view=1&name=МКБ-10_с_гиперссылками.pdf (Assessed: 11.01.2018). Russian. 17. Reed GM, Krasnov VN, Kulighina MA. [Preparation of ICD-11: Key Tasks, Principles and Stages of Revision Concerning the Classification of Mental and Behavioral Disorders]. Social’naya i klinicheskaya psikhiatriya [Social and Clinical Psychiatry]. 2013;23(4):56-61. Russian. 18. Rozhdestvina AA. Kommentaiy k Zakonu RF ot 2 iylya 1992 g. N 3185-1 «O psikhiatricheskoy pomoshhi i garantiyakh prav grazhdan pro ee okazanii» (postateynyi). SPS KonsultantPlus. 2006. Available at: http://cons-plus.ru. Assessed: 27.12.2017. Russian. 19. Shishkov SN, Grechishkina NA. [Consideration of the appeals by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation Law «On Psychiatric Care and Guarantees of Citizens Rights in Its Provision» concerning the involuntary psychiatric measures]. Psikhicheskoe zdorov’e [Mental Health]. 2014;12(1): 3-8. Russian. 20. Yastrebov VS. Sovremennaya model’ otnosheniy v psikhiatrii – partnerstvo ili paternalism? In: Pravovye i eticheskie problemy psykhiatricheskoy pomoshhi: materially nauchno-prakticheskoy ronferencii. 30 november 2009 g. Moscow; 2009. p. 211-4. Russian. 21. Appelbaum PS. Almost a Revolution: Mental Health Law and the Limits of Change. Oxford University Press, 1991. 233 р. 22. Rothman DJ. Strangers at the Bedside: a History of How Law and Bioethics Transformed Medical Decision Making. USA: BasicBooks, 1991. 303 р.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24411/1560-957X-2018-1%25x
Article Metrics
Metrics powered by PLOS ALM