The contribution of AM Khaletsky to clinical and forensic psychiatry
Suggested citation:
Kadis LR. [The contribution of AM Khaletsky to clinical and forensic psychiatry]. Rossiiskii psikhiatricheskii zhurnal [Russian Journal of Psychiatry]. 2020;(4):4-14. Russian
This review is aimed to cover the life and legacy of Abram Mironovich Khaletsky (1899–1974), the prominent Soviet psychiatrist. It submits the analysis of previously published sources, which have become a bibliographic rarity by now, as well as the recently discovered archival materials. The chronology of Khaletsky’s scientific activity is reconstructed and explored beginning from the Odessa period when he became interested in psychoanalytic ideas. His contribution to forensic psychiatric thought as well as valuable insights into the related fields of knowledge such as criminal and correctional psychology are studied. The significance of the researcher’s works in various fields of clinical psychiatry is highlighted.
Keywords Abram Mironovich Khaletsky; clinical and forensic psychiatry; psychoanalysis; criminal psychology; scientific biography
1. The State Archives of Odessa Region. Coll. R-2147, inv. 1, f. 4531. 2. Vsya Rossiya. Russkaya kniga promyshlennosti, torgovli, sel'skogo khozyaistva i administratsii. Adres-kalendar' Rossiiskoi imperii. T. 1. [Saint Petersburg]; 1900. VIII, 226 p., 3171 col. Russian. 3. Spravochnaya kniga Klyachkina. 1901. Warsaw; 1900. [29], 2132, [6] p. Russian. 4. Aikhenval'd L, Khaletskii A. K voprosu o svyazi mezhdu tuberkulezom i shizofreniei. Vrachebnoe delo. 1925;(24/26):1896–8. Russian. 5. Mishe A. (Kardash A.) U chernogo morya. Jerusalem; 2004. 388 p. Russian. 6. The Archive of Astrakhan State Medical University. Coll. R-1071, inv. 12, sheaf 23. Personal file of AM Khaletskii. 7. Otchet o deyatel'nosti Nauchnykh sobranii sotrudnikov kafedry psikhiatrii, psikhologicheskoi laboratorii Odesskogo meditsinskogo instituta i vrachei Odesskoi psikhiatricheskoi bol'nitsy (nyne preobrazovannykh v “Obshchestvo normal'noi i patologicheskoi refleksologii, psikhologii i pedologii im. akad. VM Bekhtereva”). 1923–1926 god. Odessa; 1927. 53 p. Russian. 8. ESh [Shevalev EA] Obshchestvo normal'noi i patologicheskoi refleksologii, psikhologii i pedologii im. VM Bekhtereva pri Odesskom meditsinskom institute. Sovremennaya psikhonevrologiya. 1927;5(9):215–6. Russian. 9. Zalkind AB. Zhizn' organizma i vnushenie. Moscow–Leningrad; 1927. 175 p. Russian. 10. Khaletskii AM. Psikhoanaliz lichnosti i tvorchestva Shevchenko. Sovremennaya psikhonevrologiya. 1926;2(3):347–54. Russian. 11. Neifel'd I. Dostoevskii. Psikhoanaliticheskii ocherk. Ed. S Freud. Trans. Ya Druskin. Fwd. P Guber. Leningrad–Moscow; 1925. 96 p. Russian. 12. Vygotskii LS. Psikhologiya iskusstva. Ed. MG Yaroshevskii. Moscow; 1987. 345 p. Russian. 13. Khaletskii AM. Analiz vospriyatiya khudozhestvennogo tvorchestva. Odessa; 1927. 83 p. Russian. 14. Yakubovskii G. AM Khaletskii. Analiz vospriyatiya khudozhestvennogo tvorchestva. Odessa; 1927. 83 p. [Review]. Oktyabr'. 1927;4:205–6. Russian. 15. Khaletskii A. Pervye shagi. Lichnyi arkhiv avtora. Unpublished manuscript. 1973. 2 p. Russian. 16. Khaletskii AM. K voprosu o rechevoi sputannosti u shizofrenikov. In: Ed. LI Aikhenval'd, YaM Kogan, AM Khaletskii. Yubileinyi sbornik, posvyashchennyi 35-letiyu Odesskoi okruzhnoi psikhiatricheskoi bol'nitsy imeni P Starostina. Odessa; 1927. p. 86–98. Russian. 17. Vygotskii LS. K probleme psikhologii shizofrenii. Sovetskaya nevropatologiya, psikhiatriya i psikhogigiena. 1932;1(8):352–64. Russian. 18. Sullivan HS. The language of schizophrenia. In: Ed. JS Kasanin. Language and thought in schizophrenia. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1944. p. 4–16. 19. Maier HW. Über katathyme Wahnbildung und Paranoia. Z ges Neurol Psychiat. 1912;13(5):555–610. 20. Khaletskii AM. K voprosu o seksual'noi simvolike v brede dushevnobol'nykh. Sovremennaya psikhonevrologiya. 1927;4(2):133–9. Russian. 21. Lotman YuM. Simvol v sisteme kul'tury. In: Lotman YuM. Izbrannye stat'i. Vol. 1. Stat'i po semiotike i tipologii kul'tury. Tallinn; 1992. p. 191–9. 22. Khaletskii AM. K voprosu o lechenii tyazhelykh alkogolikov. Odesskii meditsinskii zhurnal. 1929;4(2/4):83–6. Russian. 23. Veigandt V. Ehkonomnaya terapiya ehpilepsii. Trans. YaM Kogan; G Dreifus. Prakticheskie ukazaniya k primeneniyu starykh i novykh snotvornykh sredstv. Trans. AM Khaletskii. Fwd. E Shevalev. Odessa; 1926. 62 p. Russian. 24. Lazar Eh. Problemy sudebnoi psikhiatrii primenitel'no k maloletnim. Trans. YaM Kogan, AM Khaletskii. Ed. and fwd. LI Aikhenval'd. Odessa; 1927. 67 p. Russian. 25. Khaletskii AM. Polovoe vlechenie i ego sushchnost'. Odessa; 1926. 32 p. Russian. 26. Kadis LR. “Ya moloda, ya zhivu, ya lyublyu…”: tragediya Tat'yany Rozental'. Izhevsk; 2018. 147 p. Russian. 27. Freud S. Ob obshchem ponizhenii lyubovnoi zhizni. In: Freud S. Ocherki psikhologii lyubvi. Trans. MV Vul'f. Odessa; 1920. p. 15–27. Russian. 28. Freud S. “Kul'turnaya” seksual'naya moral' i sovremennaya nervoznost'. Psikhoterapiya. Obozrenie voprosov psikhicheskogo lecheniya i prikladnoi psikhologii. 1912;(1):28–47. Russian. 29. Khaletskii AM. Polovaya zhizn' i nevrasteniya. Odessa; 1926. 32 p. Russian. 30. Zalkind AB. Polovoi vopros i sovetskaya pedagogika. In: Zalkind AB. Polovoi vopros v usloviyakh sovetskoi obshchestvennosti. Collected papers. Leningrad; 1926. p. 68–103. Russian. 31. Khaletskii AM. Psikhicheski nepolnotsennye lichnosti v usloviyakh zaklyucheniya. In: Izuchenie prestupnosti i penitentsiarnaya praktika. Vol. 3. Odessa; 1930. p. 143–62. Russian. 32. Khaletskii AM. Tovarishcheskie sudy v doprakh Ukrainy. In: Izuchenie prestupnosti i penitentsiarnaya praktika. Vol. 3. Odessa; 1930. p. 99–112. Russian. 33. Frenkel' E, Khaletskii A. K tekhnike issledovaniya pravonarushitelya. In: Izuchenie prestupnosti i penitentsiarnaya praktika. Vol. 2. Fwd. S Kanarskii. Odessa; 1928. p. 156–62. Russian. 34. Khaletskii AM. K psikhologii khuliganstva. In: Izuchenie prestupnosti i penitentsiarnaya praktika. Vol. 2. Fwd. S Kanarskii. Odessa; 1928. p. 5–28. Russian. 35. Karpman B. Criminal psychodynamics: A platform. J Crim Law Criminol Police Sci. 1956;47(1):8–17. 36. Khaletskii A. O rabote tovarishcheskikh sudov. Doprovskii rabotnik. 1929;(3):4; 1929;(4):2. Russian. 37. Khaletskii A. Krest'yane i “odessity”. Doprovskii rabotnik. 1928;(4):1. Russian. 38. Khaletskii A. Obshchie kamery. Doprovskii rabotnik. 1928;(10):3. Russian. 39. Khaletskii A. Kollektivnye obsuzhdeniya. Doprovskii rabotnik. 1928;(3):3. Russian. 40. The Astrakhan State United Historical and Architectural Museum–Reserve. Museum item 43691/11. 41. The Astrakhan State United Historical and Architectural Museum–Reserve. Museum item 43691/15. 42. The Astrakhan State United Historical and Architectural Museum–Reserve. Museum item 43691/14. 43. Paruntseva IA, Kazarina IV, Usova LI. Istoriya vozniknoveniya i razvitiya Tsentra. In: Ed. TB Dmitrieva, FV Kondrat'ev. Gosudarstvennyi nauchnyi tsentr sotsial'noi i sudebnoi psikhiatrii im. VP Serbskogo. Ocherki istorii. Moscow; 1996. p. 6–106. Russian. 44. The Astrakhan State United Historical and Architectural Museum–Reserve. Museum item 43691/17. 45. The Astrakhan State United Historical and Architectural Museum–Reserve. Museum item 43691/13. 46. Khaletskii AM. Vmenyaemost' shizofrenikov. In: Ed. TsM Feinberg. Trudy Pervogo vsesoyuznogo soveshchaniya po sudebnoi psikhiatrii (Moscow, December 22–24, 1936). Moscow; 1937. p. 60–5. Russian. 47. Khaletskii AM. Voprosy vmenyaemosti pri shizofrenii. In: Ed. TsM Feinberg. Problemy sudebnoi psikhiatrii. Collected papers. Moscow; 1938. p. 65–81. Russian. 48. Khaletskii AM. Voprosy vmenyaemosti i godnosti k voennoi sluzhbe pri psikhopatiyakh. In: Ed. TsM Feinberg. Problemy sudebnoi psikhiatrii. Vol. 4. Moscow; 1944. p. 102–17. Russian. 49. Khaletskii AM. Sudebno-psikhiatricheskaya otsenka psikhopatii. In: Ed. TsM Feinberg. Sbornik organizatsionno-metodicheskikh materialov po sudebno-psikhiatricheskoi ehkspertize. Moscow; 1941. p. 29–34. Russian. 50. Khaletskii AM. Mezhdistsiplinarnye problemy psikhiatrii. In: Problemy psikhonevrologii. Scientific papers. Moscow; 1969. p. 395–8. Russian. 51. Khaletskii AM. Ponyatie “umen'shennoi vmenyaemosti” v sudebno-psikhiatricheskoi otsenke psikhopatii. In: Ed. TsM Feinberg. Psikhopatii i ikh sudebno-psikhiatricheskoe znachenie. Moscow; 1934. p. 97–106. Russian. 52. Evlakhov A. Traktovka ponyatiya vmenyaemosti. Sotsialisticheskaya zakonnost'. 1953;(10):63–4. Russian. 53. Khaletskii AM. Izuchenie i diagnostika dushevnykh zabolevanii s pomoshch'yu farmakologicheskikh sredstv. In: Ed. TsM Feinberg. Problemy sudebnoi psikhiatrii. Vol. 5. Moscow, 1946. p. 271–309. Russian. 54. Khaletskii AM. Narkodinamicheskii metod izucheniya dushevnykh zabolevanii. Nevropatologiya i psikhiatriya. 1946;15(6):13–8. Russian. 55. Khaletskii AM. Printsipy i zadachi farmakodinamicheskogo izucheniya dushevnykh zabolevanii. In: Tezisy dokladov Yubileinoi nauchnoi sessii. XXV. 1921–1946. Moscow; 1946. p. 34–6. Russian. 56. Immerman KL. Abram Mironovich Khaletskii. In: Ed. TB Dmitrieva, FV Kondrat'ev. Gosudarstvennyi nauchnyi tsentr sotsial'noi i sudebnoi psikhiatrii im. VP Serbskogo. Ocherki istorii. Moscow; 1996. p. 217–21. Russian. 57. The Astrakhan State United Historical and Architectural Museum–Reserve. Museum item 43691/21. 58. Kalashnik YaM. Kriticheskie zamechaniya o nekotorykh nauchnykh rabotakh Instituta sudebnoi psikhiatrii im. Serbskogo. Nevropatologiya i psikhiatriya. 1950;19(3):74–6. Russian. 59. Khaletskaya AA. Biografiya Khaletskogo Abrama Mironovicha. Lichnyi arkhiv avtora. Unpublished manuscript. 2011. 12 p. Russian. 60. Toshcheva TE. O professore AM Khaletskom. In: Trudy Astrakhanskoi gosudarstvennoi meditsinskoi akademii. Vol. 17. Aktual'nye voprosy psikhiatrii i nevrologii. Astrakhan; 1999. p. 3–9. Russian. 61. Khaletskii AM. O kontrastnykh formakh sindroma psikhicheskogo avtomatizma (“polozhitel'nyi” variant sindroma psikhicheskogo avtomatizma). In: Pamyati VKh Kandinskogo (K izucheniyu sindroma psikhicheskogo avtomatizma). Tezisy dokladov na ob"edinennoi konferentsii Vserossiiskogo nauchnogo meditsinskogo obshchestva nevropatologov i psikhiatrov i Astrakhanskogo obshchestva nevropatologov i psikhiatrov. Astrakhan; 1966. p. 9–10. Russian. 62. Khaletskii AM. O kontrastnykh formakh sindroma psikhicheskogo avtomatizma (“polozhitel'nyi” variant sindroma psikhicheskogo avtomatizma). In: Rokhlin LL, Fedotov DD, Khaletskii AM. Sindrom psikhicheskogo avtomatizma. Trudy ob"edinennoi konferentsii Vserossiiskogo i Astrakhanskogo nauchnykh obshchestv nevropatologov i psikhiatrov, posvyashchennoi pamyati VKh Kandinskogo. Moscow; 1969. p. 47–57. Russian. 63. Khaletskii AM. Voprosy klassifikatsii i psikhopatologii parafrenii. Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im SS Korsakova. 1973;73(1):58–65. Russian. 64. Khaletskii AM. Ostraya parafreniya. Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im SS Korsakova. 1975;75(1):91–7. Russian. 65. Khaletskii AM. Ehkspansivno-gebefrenicheskii variant periodicheskoi shizofrenii (K sistematike shizofrenii). In: Materialy V Vsesoyuznogo s"ezda nevropatologov i psikhiatrov (June 30 – July 6, 1969). Vol. 3. Doklady, podlezhashchie obsuzhdeniyu na simpoziumakh. Moscow; 1969. p. 482–4. Russian. 66. Khaletskii AM, Zasukhin DN, Orlov GA, et al. Materialy k izucheniyu toksoplazmoza. Problema toksoplazmoza v psikhonevrologicheskoi klinike. Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im SS Korsakova. 1957;57(3):360–8. Russian. 67. Khaletskii AM. O roli psikhopatologicheskogo metoda issledovaniya v diagnostike psikhozov. Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im SS Korsakova. 1959;59(1):102–6. Russian. 68. Khaletskii A. Meditsinskaya psikhologiya. Meditsinskaya gazeta. 1971;70:3. Russian. 69. Khaletskii AM. Meditsinskaya psikhologiya detskogo vozrasta i profilaktika pogranichnykh nervno-psikhicheskikh otklonenii u detei i podrostkov. In: Materialy k III Vserossiiskoi nauchnoi konferentsii po nevrologii i psikhiatrii detskogo vozrasta (November 15–18, 1971). Moscow; 1971. p. 139–41. Russian. 70. Khaletskii AM. Urovni psikhicheskoi deyatel'nosti v norme i patologii. Fwd. LL Rokhlin. Moscow; 1970. 159 p. Russian. 71. Freierov OE. AM Khaletskii. Urovni psikhicheskoi deyatel'nosti v norme i patologii. Fwd. LL Rokhlin. Moscow; 1970. 159 p. [Review]. Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im SS Korsakova. 1972;72(8):1249–50. Russian. 72. The State Archive of Astrakhan Region. Coll. R-1071, inv. 9, f. 149. 73. Khaletskii AM. Ispolnenie vrachebnogo dolga i sovremennaya meditsina Fwd. AV Ulezko. Astrakhan; 2000. 71 p. Russian. 74. Ulezko AV. Foreword. In: Khaletskii AM. Ispolnenie vrachebnogo dolga i sovremennaya meditsina. Astrakhan; 2000. p. 4–5. Russian. 75. Khaletskii AM. O smene sindromov v techenii periodicheskikh psikhozov. Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im SS Korsakova. 1970;70(4):556–60. Russian.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24411/1560-957X-2020-10401
Article Metrics
Metrics powered by PLOS ALM